Skip to main content

Ready to hire?

Post your job in minutes, browse real reviews and choose who to speak to.Post a job

Need some tips or advice?

Ask a question
Fencing

Fencing once shared with neighbour dispute

Anonymous user 03/03/2024 - 3.47 PM

My neighbour & I live in Semi Detached houses. At the rear there was a shared fence with closeboard panels fixed to wooden posts. When there were strong winds the fence often tilted & swayed. After a spell of strong winds & frequent straightening of the fence. I decided it would be better to install a new fence with concrete posts & gravel boards. I suggested to my neighbour that if they were willing to share the cost of the new fence that backed onto their garden, I would ask the contractors to replace the whole fence at the same time. The offer was declined. I went ahead & had the new fence installed along the part that backed onto my garden. My end concrete post is stood next to their end wooden post, but not attached to it, effectively becoming two fences independent of each other. I also had a shed put into the corner which i hoped gives added protection to the new fence from the winds. This was three years ago & no more was said about it. Following recent strong winds their fence wilted quite badly & needed straightening. They've complained to me that it wouldn't have happened had the fencing contractors done their job properly & fixed their fence panel into my concrete post. They've asked me to get it sorted. Are they correct, is it my responsibility ? Edit: Our gardens are both East facing. The single file fence goes along the bottom of both our gardens (left to right). Where the new fencing ends the concrete post stands next to their old wooden post where their old fence begins. So effectively there's two fences next to each other single file. They're now saying the contractors should've replaced their end wooden post with my concrete post & fixed their end panel into it. This wasn't agreed or mentioned at the time. It doesn't sit right with me

Are you a tradesperson and able to answer this question?

4 Answers

Tree expert clearences

Rating: 4.7 out of 5
Willesden, London
The responsibility for maintaining and repairing a fence shared between neighbors can depend on various factors, including local regulations and any prior agreements between the neighbors. In the UK, there isn't a strict legal requirement for neighbors to share the cost of a boundary fence or to maintain it jointly, unless there is a specific agreement in place. Based on the information you provided, it seems that you took the initiative to replace the part of the fence on your side, and your neighbor declined to share the cost. In this case, it's generally understood that each neighbor is responsible for the maintenance and repair of the side of the fence that is on their property. Your decision to have your concrete post next to their wooden post without attaching them may have created two separate, independent fences. If there was no explicit agreement or understanding that the replacement of the fence would include their side, it is reasonable for you to maintain your side of the fence. Your neighbors might have a preference for how they would like the fence to be fixed, but if there was no prior agreement or discussion about this when the replacement took place, they may not have a legal basis to insist that you modify your fence to accommodate their preferences. It's advisable to review any local regulations or guidelines regarding shared fences in your area and, if necessary, consult with a legal professional to clarify your rights and responsibilities in this situation. Additionally, open communication with your neighbor to discuss the situation and possibly find an amicable resolution may be beneficial.
Answered3 January 2024
1

Weald and Downland Limited

Rating: 5 out of 5
Lewes
I would say it's there responsibility to repair there half of the fence, you have renewed your half, and that's all fine, if they had contributed in the first place then I the whole fence would be new and erected in one line, not two.
Answered3 January 2024
1

jj’s driveways & landscaping

Rating: 5 out of 5
Alfreton
No if you have put a fence in front of the old one then that is up to you it has nothing to do with the neighbours
Answered3 January 2024
0

Anonymous user

This is completely unfair and unreasonable what your neighbour is proposing, if your new fence is free standing of there's you would be in no way responsible for rectifying there issue with the post as this would of happened regardless of you installing your new fence. Please direct email us if you need further advice.
Answered7 January 2024
0