Skip to main content

Ready to hire?

Post your job in minutes, browse real reviews and choose who to speak to.Post a job

Need some tips or advice?

Ask a question
Plastering & Rendering

Since my ceiling was put in I can hear upstairs. Has my builder messed up?

Anonymous user 23/02/2024 - 2.55 PM

I recently hired a builder to do some work on my flat in a Victorian conversion. This included replacing the ceiling in the living room, which had at some point been water damaged and was sagging. I also wanted downlights put in. When he took the old ceilnig down it seemed to be some kind of "wattle and dawb" construction with lots of small strips of wood with the plaster on top. He replaced it with modern plasterboard, though we did not discuss the details of the materials as i assumed there would be not much difference from what was there before. Before the ceilnig was replaced, I never heard the flat upstairs. Since it was replaced I hear every footstep and one of their floorboards has a really loud squeak. What materials should my builder have used? Is it common for modern ceilnigs to have a much poorer sound-proofing quality than old ones? Thanks!

Are you a tradesperson and able to answer this question?

6 Answers

Secure Carpentry

Rating: 5 out of 5
Swansea
Hi there, unfortunately new ceiling are less sound proofing , Lath and plaster ceilings are superior sound proofing when coated with thick lime plaster. It's very difficult to block foot noise , a dense insulation could have been used, or a thicker underlay on the floor above . Some times a false lower ceiling so no impact and extra dead space can help. Ideally though , Depending on how bad the ceiling was, you could have overboarded the lath and plaster , just meaning to plaster board and fix with longer screws. Hope this is somewhat help full
Answered13 February 2015
4

Anonymous user

It sounds like your builder could have used a standard plasterboard, it would have been advisable to use Gyproc Soundblock, slightly more expensive but it does what it says on the tin, the high volumes of noise experienced in many areas today, you may sometimes require a board that delivers exceptionally high levels of sound insulation. Gyproc Soundbloc high mass core gives the board vastly superior protection from the effects of noise. It is easy to install and has a good impact resistance. You will experience the noise more now as it sounds like the old ceiling was a lath plaster. Apart from reducing the risk of cracking, lath-and-plaster is superior to plasterboard for its sound-proofing properties. Traditional lime plaster is much denser than the gypsum from which plasterboard is made, and this helps absorb low-frequency sound. Also, the way the plaster oozes between the laths leaves an irregular surface which cuts down reverberation and echo, similar to the "egg box" acoustic lining materials used in recording studios. Hope this explains a little bit for you......
Answered13 February 2015
2

Anonymous user

He would of removed the old Lathe & Plaster, With regards to what he replaced it with, He replaced it correctly by the sounds of things, unless you instructed him to reduce the sound from upstairs, then some form of acoustic barrier and double boarding & skimmed
Answered13 February 2015
2

Anonymous user

Hi it seems your builder only used one layer of plasterboard instead of two sheets that are requiresd and used no fiberglass insulation between the joists.so all your got is a open space between your ceiling and there floor . I hope this makes sense Paul at totalplastering
Answered13 February 2015
1

Anonymous user

Hello, The builder that done this work for you had removed lantern plaster made up of horse hair and lime plaster the batten strips that you saw was the way they held the mix to the ceiling before painting the ceiling. and when you take this down it makes a lot of mess and loads come from a small area. he would have taken the battens off and re-placed 12/inch plaster board to the area and fixed to the joist, then plastered the board. but to help sound proof he could have used lagging as you would have in the attic. but you can still sound proof the ceiling to stop the noise to a good level if you wanted to by? Should you wish to have this done contact me ill be happy to help you.
Answered13 February 2015
1

Terry Owen Carpentry

Rating: 5 out of 5
Swanley
did he put any insulation between the joists before plasterboarding the ceiling
Answered13 February 2015
0