Central Heating Question

Worcester greenstar junior 28i vs vaillant ecotec pro 28 combi

Which boiler is suitable for a 3 bed semi with 1 bathroom?

Worcester Greenstar Junior 28I or Vaillant ecoTEC Pro 28 Combi????

7 Answers

Best Answer

Vaillant has a stainless steel heat exchanger Worcester is aluminium- in my experience NO contest go for Stainless every time better condensing cycle

Answered 13th Aug 2011

Total Heating

Member since 31 Dec 2009

Valliant everytime,can't even switch the worcester off on the boiler,you have no control of the hot water temp,if you are an accredited installer a 3,4,5 year warranty can be added at a small cost

Answered 13th Aug 2011

Paul Caton Gas Services

Member since 23 Mar 2010

Worcester definitely, if you can afford it go for the 30si, then you can have temperature control on the hot water, the only complaint i ever get from customers regarding worcester 28i jr is the hot water is too hot because you cant control the hot water temp. The aftercare with worcester is brilliant, if anythink goes wrong with it they are out the next day.

Regards

Matt

Answered 13th Aug 2011

J.M plumbing & heating

Member since 8 Aug 2011

worcester every time the heat exchanger is guaranteed for 10 years and the heat transfer on the heat exchanger is the best i know the arguments about stainless steel and all that and i used to fit viessmanns all the time but wait till they go wrong and they dont really want to know get worcester fitted and you may get a 7yr warrenty if you get the right fitter.
regards
am heating

Answered 14th Dec 2012

AM heating

Member since 13 May 2009

Both are has good as each other, both will do the job required.

Bill
Pipe DReams Plumbing Services

Answered 14th Aug 2011

Pipe Dreams Plumbing Services

Member since 9 Sep 2009

Both would be suitable from what you have described,I would go for the worcester i have the vaillant in my house just over 2yrs and its broke 3 times.
It would be best to advertise locally and get quotes if you are anywere near me give me a call.

Answered 14th Aug 2011

IAN PRICE PLUMBING&HEATING

Member since 1 Jun 2008

I think vaillant and Worcester are very similar and that's all we fit either those two, have a look at a boiler called viessman give you 5 year warranty, about £200 cheaper than those two boilers you get a longer guarantee, the viessman most engineers don't fit but only the other day I see one fitted and there very quiet. Good luck with your boiler, any questions contact me no problem

Answered 13th Aug 2011

plumber/heating engineer

Member since 12 Aug 2011

Need help with your project?

We have tradesmen ready to help you. Post a job, read reviews and hire today.

Post a job

Need some help?

Post a job on MyBuilder to find quality, local Heating Engineers who can help you with your project.

Search all questions